724-940-5000 or www.otbbicyclecafe.com
Pedal or paddle (or jog or drive) to this rustic-looking spot, with its lakeside patio, tasty drafts, and outdoors-themed offerings, including the Trail Builder burger, with bacon and onion straws, and the Pig Hill Press, a Cuban-style sandwich named after an infamous local incline.
Other Finalists
2nd: Scratch Food & Beverage, Troy Hill
3rd: Pear and the Pickle, Troy Hill