5880 Ellsworth Ave., Shadyside
412-362-7387 or www.petagogypgh.com
If a plastic toy and run-of-the-mill pet food are all you desire for your pet, a big-box store probably has you covered. But all items at Petagogy are hand-picked. Pet food and snacks are healthful; pet toys and supplies are selected because they are unique, and many are made from recycled materials.
2nd: Burton's Total Pet, multiple locations
3rd: Animal Nature, Regent Square